06/26/25 Afternoon CommStock Report – E-Mail Exchange on HF639

Below is a written conversation between my State Senator and myself regarding the CO2 pipeline issue. First, Senator Rowley’s email to me:   “According to a poll taken last September 2024, 84% of Iowans said they are against the use of eminent domain for private projects.  Governor Reynolds and I are Republicans, and while we may disagree on some issues, we have a mutual respect for each other regardless of differences which is important for civil conversation.  The Governor and I also pay close attention to the voters and the Iowa GOP, whose platform for years has stated: ‘We oppose federal or state government taking private property away from the owner for the use of another private party.  Eminent domain should be used for public use.’  Supreme Court Justices: Scalia, O’Connor, and Thomas would not support this action.  All three wrote scathing dissents when Kelo vs New London was decided years ago.  I respect their opinions based on the constitutionality regarding when eminent domain is warranted and necessary for ‘public use.’  If you haven’t you may want to read their opinions for context. The Iowa House voted overwhelming for this bill 85-10.  Since I was elected in 2022 the senate…